The Encorat project proposes temporary management of gillnet fisheries to protect cormorants

Led by the Animal Ecology Group of the CIM-UVigo, their conclusions were presented this Monday. The installation of LED lights in the nets was not effective in reducing accidental bird mortality

The great crested cormorant is an endangered seabird that in recent years has suffered a significant decline throughout Spain due to overfishing of its prey species, oil pollution and, according to several previous studies by the Animal Ecology Group of the Marine Research Center of the University of Vigo, accidental mortality in gillnet fishing gear. Precisely to address this last aspect, the Encorat project, Actions to reduce accidental mortality of the Great Cormorant (Phalacrocorax aristotelis) in gillnet fishing gear in the North Atlantic Marine Demarcation, was launched at the beginning of this year. The Vigo research group, with the collaboration of the Department of Biology of Organisms and Systems of the University of Oviedo and funding from the Biodiversity Foundation through the Pleamar program, focused, on the one hand, on evaluating the effectiveness of a prototype of LED-type light devices installed in gillnets to prevent accidents and, on the other, on carrying out a study on the feeding areas of individuals and their overlap with fishing areas.

The team, led by GEA researcher José Carlos Noguera, presented their conclusions this Monday after a year of work in Galician and Portuguese waters, in a virtual event through the UVigo Remote Campus, in which he was accompanied by researchers Álvaro Barros and Alberto Velando, from the University of Vigo, and David Álvarez, from the University of Oviedo. Barros explained that during the last year, 46 juvenile birds were tagged with GPS devices in different breeding colonies on the islands of Ons and Sagres, in the Atlantic Islands National Park, “which is where there are enough nests and accessible locations to work”. This action allowed more than 18,000 locations to be obtained and the spatial analysis of the data obtained indicates that “there are sex-related differences in post-generative dispersal movements, with females being the ones that disperse the most”. Furthermore, he highlighted that the analyses indicate that the area of ​​juveniles’ spawning increases with age, being located within a maximum radius of 4km around the breeding colonies during the months of May and June, and later being located at a maximum of 8km. Based on these data, the researchers recommend “carrying out temporary management of gillnet fisheries in the areas of greatest use by juvenile birds, for example, limiting the number of boats that operate close (<4km) to the colonies between May and August. In these special protection areas, points out Barros, “it would be necessary to consider limiting use and it would not be a bad idea to start talking about limiting certain gears at certain times of the year in certain areas, if with this we manage to significantly reduce the mortality of threatened species”.

LED devices have not proven their effectiveness

The other line of research of the project aimed to reduce the accidental capture of the cormorant by installing LED-type light devices in gillnets. The idea was that the lights would allow the birds to detect the presence of the nets in the water and thus avoid them. After the field experiments carried out in Galicia and Asturias, specifically in two coastal boats in the ports of Tapia de Casariego and Laxe, they were able to demonstrate that the installation of these devices in the gear has no effect on fishing activity, neither on the number of catches nor on the economic performance of the fishing days. Another important conclusion of the study is the confirmation of “the suspicions of the high mortality that occurs in this type of gillnet”, since during the course of the project they were able to verify the death of at least five individuals in the gear of three boats, as José Carlos Noguera explains. “It may not seem like many, but if we take into account that it was during 15 days of work and that in all of Galicia there are around 1000 boats with permission for this type of gear and another 221 in Asturias, we can get an idea of ​​the conflict that exists with this type of activity”, although he stressed that not all of them work in conflict areas for the cormorant. The results are also very relevant, since “this is the first study carried out in the North Atlantic demarcation that demonstrates the capture of cormorants in gillnet fishing gear”, as Álvaro Barros pointed out.

The other part of the study, which aimed to evaluate the efficiency of installing LEDs in the nets, did not obtain the expected results, since the scientists were unable to observe a positive effect of these devices in reducing the accidental mortality of these birds. However, the results do allow us to confirm, the researcher points out, “an association of mortality with certain environmental conditions that could have affected the effectiveness of the devices”. Given these data, the project’s principal investigator José Carlos Noguera points to the need to carry out larger-scale studies on the effectiveness of these deterrent devices, as well as to design variations of them.

In conclusion, the researchers consider it advisable to carry out a detailed in situ study of the use of gillnets and its relationship with mortality, as well as to implement mitigation measures in specially protected areas, such as the Natura Network areas, which have significant populations of this species, including the Atlantic Islands of Galicia National Park in this group.

The research activity of the CIM is supported by the Xunta de Galicia and the European Union through their co-financing under the Galicia ERDF Operational Programme 2014–2020.

Source: DUVI

Edificio Filomena Dato
Campus de Vigo
36310 Vigo. Galicia. (Spain)